New publications: Participatory Collaboration Mapping/Collaborative Sensemaking of Design-Enabled Urban Innovations: The MappingDESIGNSCAPES Case

DESIGNSCAPES was an EU H2020 program for building capacity for design-enabled innovation in urban environments. In the MappingDESIGNSCAPES project we piloted a participatory collaboration mapping approach for cross-case sensemaking across design-enabled urban innovation initiatives:

• A. de Moor, E. Papalioura, E. Taka, D. Rapti, A. Wolff, A. Knutas, and T. te Velde (2023). Participatory Collaboration Mapping of Design-Enabled Urban Innovations: The MappingDESIGNSCAPES Case. In R. Polovina, S. Polovina, and N. Kemp (eds.), Measuring Ontologies for Value Enhancement: Aligning Computing Productivity with Human Creativity for Societal Adaptation. MOVE 2020, Communications in Computer and Information Science, vol. 1694, Springer, Cham, pp. 171-202. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-22228-3_8 [Preprint]

Wicked societal problems, such as environmental issues and climate change, are complex, networked problems involving many intertwined issues, no optimal solutions, and numerous stakeholders. Cities are problem owners and living labs for finding solutions through design-enabled innovation initiatives. However, to reach collective impact, it is paramount that these initiatives can learn from one another and align efforts through collaborative sensemaking. In the MappingDESIGNSCAPES project, we piloted a participatory collaboration mapping approach for cross-case sensemaking across design-enabled urban innovation initiatives. We used the CommunitySensor methodology for participatory community network mapping and the Kumu online network visualization tool to help representatives of three urban prototype cases share and collectively make sense of their design lessons. In this first of two papers, we describe how we set up the MappingDESIGNSCAPES project as part of the DESIGNSCAPES urban design innovations R&D program; how we created a conceptual model of the collaboration ecosystems around design-enabled urban innovations; and co-created a visual knowledge base centered around the case and cross-case maps grounded in this conceptual model. We end this paper with a discussion of participatory mapping lessons learned. In the accompanying paper [1], we show how we used this visual knowledge base to drive a process of collaborative sensemaking to share lessons learned across cases.

Wicked societal problems, such as environmental issues and climate change, are complex, networked problems involving numerous intertwined issues, no optimal solutions, and a wide range of stakeholders. Cities are problem owners and living labs for finding solutions through design-enabled innovation initiatives. However, to reach collective impact, it is paramount that these initiatives can learn from one another and align efforts through collaborative sensemaking. In the MappingDESIGNSCAPES project, we piloted a participatory collaboration mapping approach for cross-case sensemaking across design-enabled urban innovation initiatives. We used the CommunitySensor methodology for participatory community network mapping together with the Kumu online network visualization tool to help representatives of three urban prototype cases share and collectively make sense of their design lessons learnt. In this second of two papers, we build on the participatory mapping foundation introduced in [1]. We describe the collaborative sensemaking approach used, then present the core collaboration patterns and common perspectives that form the sensemaking scaffolding. We show how we collaboratively made sense by first taking individual perspectives, then making common sense together. An extended discussion puts our findings in a larger context of how an approach like MappingDESIGNSCAPES can be used to move from collaborative sensemaking to collective impact in design-driven urban innovation.